MAURY ALLEN
"THE
ECHOING GREEN"
A nostalgic baseball event with four lifelong friendsBy MAURY ALLEN
of TheColumnists.com
"Those friends thou hast, and their adoption tried, grapple them to thy soul with hoops of steel." -- William Shakespeare.
I spent two nights in the last couple of weeks experiencing two of the most remarkable friendships between former baseball players, all four well into their 80s, all four legendary figures of the game.
Joe Garagiola and Yogi Berra, friends from across the street in the Dago Hill section of St. Louis and Ralph Branca and Bobby Thomson, linked by the Shot Heard Round the World, gathered on separate nights to express this cherished bonding at Yogi Berras Museum and Learning Center on the campus of Montclair State University in Little Falls, New Jersey.
Garagiola was the first from that area to be signed to a professional baseball contract--for $500--and became a 1946 St. Louis World Series catcher. Berra, a World War II Navy vet from Normandys D-Day, showed up at the Stadium in his sailor suit the previous year. They were neighborhood pals.
Whatever games we played, Yogi organized them, said Garagiola, who spoke of his boyhood pal known as "Lawdie" because his Italian-speaking mother couldnt pronounce her sons name as Larry. He could do whatever he wanted to do in any game.
Garagiola spoke of the Yogi-isms even muttered as a kid by this son of a shoe factory worker, of the warmth and loyalty to the friendship he has shown for more than 70 years, of the modesty one of the games greatest stars always exhibited.
Berras career remained in baseball as a Hall of Fame player, a Yankees World Series hero, a coach, a manager and the owner of one of the games most recognizable faces.
Garagiolas career drifted off into broadcasting, after a .257 career average, with play by play with the Yankees and a long stay at televisions Today show.
Through it all they shared their lives, connected as adults, bonded with the growth of families.
Berra married the former Carmen Short of St. Louis, a waitress at the time at the famed Stan (Musials) and Biggies restaurant.
We used to go in every night and sit in the corner. We couldnt afford to eat, said Garagiola. One day I asked Yogi why we kept going in there and he said it was because he liked to look at Carmen. I told him to ask her out for a date so I could get something to eat someplace else.
When Yogi and Carmen married in 1949, some family and friends criticized Yogi for not marrying an Italian girl.
They had their chance, said Yogi.
A new book entitled "The Echoing Green: The Untold Story of Bobby Thomson, Ralph Branca and the Shot Heard Round the World" by Joshua Prager (Pantheon, $26/95) was the centerpiece of the discussion at Yogis by the former Brooklyn Dodgers pitcher and the former New York Giants third baseman.
October 3, 1951. The Giants win the pennant, the Giants win the pennant, the Giants win the pennant, howled Giants broadcaster Russ Hodges after Thomson smacked Brancas high inside fastball into the lower stands of the Polo Grounds for the pennant-winning homer.
It is the single most dramatic home run in baseball history. Six years ago Prager, in an article in the Wall Street Journal, spelled out the long-rumored tale that the Giants cheated their way to victory that day--and for many weeks prior--by stealing signs through a centerfield telescope and an electronic communications system.
Backup infielder Hank Schenz had brought the telescope to the Giants with him when he came over from the Pirates. Coach Herman Franks and bullpen catcher Sal Yvars, who talked freely about the spying for years, did most of the signaling to teammates.
The Giants, with the help at home from the sign stealing, went 37-7 to knock down a Brooklyn lead that had reached 13 ½ games on August 11.
Their pitching was terrific and the Dodgers played only a couple of games over .500 as they blew a six game lead with little more than a week to go.
Then came the playoff and the Thomson homer off Branca for the pennant.
The accidental event linked Branca and Thomson in baseball history. Four months later the two players stood on a stage in Manhattans Waldorf Hotel at a Baseball Writers Dinner and sang Tony Bennetts popular Because of You with lyrics about the event written by New York baseball writer Arthur Mann.
They repeated their number 50 years later as they each neared the age of eighty at another Baseball Writers Dinner.
After retirement from the game, Branca sold insurance and Thomson worked for a paper manufacturing company.
They were thrown together often at baseball banquets and historic events of the game. They connected well as exceptional, decent, honorable, moral human beings. In 1991 and again in 2001 they toured the land spreading the gospel of that moment.
Were like a married couple, Branca said at Yogis Museum. Were tied together at the hip.
It was clear there was deep affection by these two gentlemen as they talked of the events of 55 years ago. Prager did an enormous research job in putting his book together after five and a half years. He makes clear the unique bonding of these two very different men, the hard-throwing pitcher from Mount Vernon, New York, in the big leagues at 18 and the insecure, shy Scottish immigrant, carried to the shores of the USA, where baseball became his national identification.
No player in baseball history ever reacted with more dignity, poise and courage to adversity than Branca did after his 1951 mis-adventure.
No player ever dealt with the drama of his accomplishment with more modesty than Thomson.
Still, the ugliness of the sign-stealing hovers over the event.
Thomson never could come to terms with the cheating.
Branca signed my copy of Pragers book with Best Wishes. The Giants stole the pennant. Period. Ralph Branca.©2006 by Maury Allen. The Maury Allen caricature is ©2001 by Jim Hummel. The book cover illustration is courtesy of Pantheon Books. This column first posted Oct. 2, 2006.
You can comment on this column online. Please address your message to either "The Editors" or Maury Allen. To send an email, click here and don't forget to mention Maury's name: talkback@thecolumnists.com
HOME About Us Index To
ArchivesTalkback Contact Us