TheColumnists.com

 MAURY ALLEN

 

BROTHERS IN SPORTS
 

 At left, Peyton Manning, MVP at last year's SuperBowl. At right,
his brother Eli, this
year's SuperBowl MVP.
 

The Mannings latest pair
of famous sports brothers

By MAURY ALLEN
of TheColumnists.com

 

There’s an old joke about the funeral of a Jewish man with the rabbi standing over the deceased and demanding someone from the congregation speak about him.

“We can’t continue with the service,” the rabbi pleads, “until someone talks about the late Mr. Cohen.”

No one moves. Finally an elderly man makes his way from the back of the congregation to the rostrum, clears his voice and announces, “The brother was worse.”

Well, this time the brother was just as good or maybe, because of the historic proportions for this game, even a little better.

Peyton Manning was the MVP in the 2007 Super Bowl and younger brother Eli Manning was MVP in the 2008 Super Bowl with the Giants 17-14 victory keeping the Patriots from an undefeated 19-0 season. Oldest brother, Cooper, first of NFL star Archie Manning’s three sons, was injured early in his college playing career.

This all reminded me of the brother acts in sports.

The DiMaggios were around when I was a kid, Joe DiMaggio, of course, the best of the bunch as the star centerfielder with the Yankees and that 56-game hitting streak in 1941. Little brother Dom DiMaggio was a pretty good centerfielder for the Boston Red Sox and the guy teammate Ted Williams leaned on when the press beat up on him.

Then, without much glory, was older brother Vince DiMaggio who was a strikeout leader with the Pittsburgh Pirates until Ralph Kiner came along.

There was a fourth brother, Tom DiMaggio, who ran the family restaurant, DiMaggio’s, on San Francisco’s Fisherman’s Wharf. It was a popular sports hangout with traditional bad food and high prices for tourists.

When I was writing a book on Joe DiMaggio in 1975 I traveled to San Francisco to interview brother Tom who was pretty forthcoming about his famous baseball siblings.

“Joe always said I was the best player in the family,” Tom quickly reminded me, “but I hurt my knee as a kid.”

I asked Tom why brother Joe quit baseball after the 1951 season at such a relatively early age of 36 when Yankees owner Dan Topping wanted to give him another couple of years at the then whopping salary of $100,000 a year.

“Don’t you know? He wasn’t Joe DiMaggio anymore,” he replied.

I was a kid in Brooklyn when my first baseball hero, Dixie Walker, won the batting title in 1944. The sportswriters of the day demeaned the feat because they said all the good hitters were in the service.

Dixie gained more fame in 1947 when he was supposed to be the leader of the plot by Brooklyn Dodger players to keep Jackie Robinson off the team. His brother, Harry Walker, won the batting title that year playing for two teams, Philadelphia and St. Louis, a feat never before or since equaled.

One of the players who kept Walker out of the Brooklyn lineup for a while shortly after he joined the team was Paul Waner. He and brother Lloyd, both future Hall of Famers, were wonderful hitters. Paul Waner was also a recognized drunk.

Paul Waner hit .354 in 1937. His bosses figured he could do even better if he quit the booze. He stopped drinking and hit .280 the next year. Then he was urged to resume his old habits and hit .328.

“Sometimes I saw two balls,” he once explained, “and I could always hit the bottom one.”

There was a dynamic battery of pitcher Mort Cooper and catcher Walker Cooper with the Cardinals in the 1940s. They helped beat the Brooklyn Dodgers out of a couple of pennants in 1942 and 1943.

The Cardinals had another brother act in pitchers Dizzy Dean and Daffy Dean, supposedly named Jay Hanna and Paul. Paul Dean once pitched a no-hitter in the second game of a double header after Dizzy had pitched a one hitter in the first game.

“If I'd-a know’d he would pitch a no-hitter,” Dizzy said, “I'd-a pitched one, too.”

The brothers I remembered seeing play for the San Francisco Giants against the New York Mets in the old Polo Grounds were the three Alou brothers, Felipe, Matty and Jesus.

In 1963. They were unimpressed with their feat because they had done it so many times before in their native Dominican Republic.

With the DiMaggios, the Waners, the Walkers and the Alous, there used to be an old baseball trivia question that got laughs.

“What team of brothers hit the most home runs in the game’s history?”

The answer was the Aarons, 755 by Hank and 13 by Tommie. Barry Bonds has passed Hank Aaron in homers, with or without the help of steroids as only time will tell, but he is still behind the brothers’ total of 768

In this scribe’s opinion, grammatical or not, the Aaron brothers were better.

©2008 by Maury Allen. This column first posted Feb. 11, 2008.


You can comment on this column online. Please address your message to either "The Editors" or Maury Allen. To send an email, click here and don't forget to mention Maury's name: talkback@thecolumnists.com

 HOME

 About Us

 Index To
Archives

 Talkback

 Contact Us