TheColumnists.com

 MAURY ALLEN
GOING BY THE BOOK


 A NEW 'LEAGUE of THEIR OWN'?

 

Is it time again for a new

women's baseball league?

By MAURY ALLEN
of TheColumnists.com

 

About 30 years ago I sat in the press box at Yankee Stadium watching a bad Yankee team struggle through another losing game.

A bunch of us old sportswriters--I was in my early forties at the time--killed the dead time by telling dirty jokes, searching out the pretty girls in the stands with binoculars and making plans for the post-game beer fest.

That’s what old sportswriters did until the game ended and the rat-tat-tat of typewriters (little machines that made words appear on paper) filled the air at Yankee Stadium. I was a two-fingered speedy typist and finished my story with a flourish and announced to a couple of colleagues, “I’ll see you in the press room.”

We all collected there after games while the traffic jams thinned out around the Stadium. We talked baseball, we bragged about how our stories made the back page of our newspapers and we told lies about our conquests on the road.

This was macho city.

Then the gals showed up.

Sportswriting gals. Female reporters. Ladies in need of a different bathroom on that crowded press box level.

Women had invaded the sanctity of the male hideouts. The world would never be the same. No Pulitzer Prize winners among them yet but clearly separate and equal. The Jackie Robinsons of the modern computers.

All of this shocking social trauma came back with a rush as I read Carolyn M. Trombe’s revealing and delightful book on Dottie Wiltse Collins: The Strikeout Queen of the All-American Girls Professional Baseball League ($24.95, McFarland and Company, Inc.) after a recent visit to the Baseball Hall of Fame in Cooperstown.

Women in baseball are well represented there now and well understood through the charming film of their experiences in "A League of Their Own."

One quick fact about Wiltse, who became Collins after marrying a California sailor named Harvey Collins: She was not the character Geena Davis played in the film as Dottie.

“That was a composite character,” said Trombe. “All of the characters in the film were composites.”

Collins was a kid softball pitcher who had a creative father. He saw that his daughter loved the game of baseball and encouraged her all the way into her professional shot with the Minneapolis Millerettes and Fort Wayne Daisies. She won 117 games as a pitcher in six seasons after the league, created during World War II in 1943 by Chicago Cubs boss, Phil Wrigley, took off.

It all came to historic realization in 1988 when the Baseball Hall of Fame made the efforts and dedication of some 175 professional female baseball players during the war years a lasting, significant, historic part of the game.

Why not?

From my earliest days as a baseball fan in Brooklyn rooting for the Dodgers until those days in the 1970s when women joined us all in the press box, females have been a vital core of the game.

Mothers took sons to baseball games in the 1930s and 1940s because fathers worked impossible hours during Depression and World War II America. Ladies Days created much attention and action. Hilda Chester, the cow bell lady, was Brooklyn’s most famous fan.

Many men were away in service during those years of 1943-1945 and the league continued entertaining fans after they returned.

Collins only played six seasons but made it through World War II, a marriage and the birth of a daughter. Let a man try that.

Trombe said at a recent lecture at Yogi Berra’s Museum in Little Falls, New Jersey that there is much interest in forming a new professional league for girls as was done during the years of World War II.

“Dottie and all the others who played in the league are inspirational figures for today’s young women. There really is no reason that a professional baseball league for girls would not be successful,” Trombe said.

Jackie Robinson integrated baseball racially in 1947. No female has been able to integrate big league baseball sexually. None seem interested in doing it.

“That doesn’t mean girls don’t want to play in a professional baseball league,” Trombe said.

I never thought I would sit next to a female in a baseball press box, move left while they moved right to their rest rooms or tell the same stupid jokes in front of them we used to tell about them.

One of the issues still being battled over in the Iraqi constitution proposals is equality for women.

Women are still fighting some good fights in this country for true equality.

They don’t want to face Roger Clemens or Alex Rodriguez.

Trombe makes it clear they do want to face each other in a professional league for their own love of the game and the joy of the fans.

Geena Davis will be a fictional President on television this fall. She was a fictional Dottie Collins.

It may be time again for a factual female professional baseball league again. Play ball again. Keep the skirts short.

©2005 by Maury Allen. The Maury Allen caricature is ©2001 by Jim Hummel. The book cover reproduction is courtesy of the McFarland Co. This column first posted Sept. 5, 2005.

You can comment on this column online. Please address your message to either "The Editors" or Maury Allen. To send an email, click here: talkback@thecolumnists.com

 HOME

 About Us

 Index To
Archives

 Talkback

 Contact Us