JIM BAWDEN
VINCENTE MINNELLI
and his MOVIESAt left, Vincente Minnelli in his early days at MGM, where he made his reputation
directing some of the studio's immortal classics, including (righi) "Meet Me in
St. Louis," the ever-engaging Judy Garland musical.
Minnelli talked candidly
about his many films
EDITOR'S NOTE:
In June of 1979, Jim Bawden arranged and conducted a private one-on-one interview with film director Vincente Minnelli. Bawden was at that time the TV columnist for The Toronto Star. He now
revisits that interview in a three-part series for us, giving us rare
insight into the thinking of the great director who died in 1986.By JIM BAWDEN
of TheColumnists.co;m
I hadn't really expected to land an exclusive interview with Vincente Minnelli so easily when I impulsively phoned his home on that sweltering day in June of 1979, but Minnelli himself answered the phone and immediately agreed to talk with me."This afternoon," he told me."It's the only time I've got open in the next few weeks."
Minnelli's home was on a corner lot near the famous Beverly Hills Hotel, away from the traffic noise on Sunset Boulevard, behind a line of trees. His fourth wife, Lee, a publicist, opened the door after the first ring and whispered, "Beware! Hes very inarticulate. Hes been fretting all morning about this. So be on your guard.
As she guided me upstairs to his study, I glimpsed downstairs rooms all decorated in white. Minnelli was dressed in his usual canary yellow sports jacket. The room was medium sized, painted white and soft yellow, with library shelves stacked with art books. On a desk illustrations were spread out for a project on Zelda Fitzgerald that he intended as a star vehicle for his daughter Liza Minnelli. (The film was never made).
Minnelli looked a bit uneasy at first, so I tried to put him at his ease by mentioning Id just watched on TV his film noir classic, "Undercurrent" (1947) with Katharine Hepburn, Robert Taylor and Robert Mitchum and found his use of black and white just as exciting as his trademark use of bold colors.
Shooting in black and white was always a challenge at Metro, he said. They wanted every shot to gleam. But some scenes had to be under-lit, you know, to get the tension developing. I felt 'The Cobweb' would have succeeded only in black and white. Color took all that suspense away. It just drained off the tension. People expected a comedy, it looked so lovely.
I was there to discuss his feature films. He'd specified "no personal questions, please."He brightened up when I asked him to describe the feeling the first time he walked onto the MGM lot as a director.
Well, Id worked at Paramount (in 1937). But MGM was not only bigger, it had everything Id ever needed. Why Arthur Freed picked me, I just dont know. MGM was into a drive to recruit younger directors. Clarence Brown, Jack Conway, Robert Leonard were seen as an aging cadre. From shorts, Metro plucked George Sidney and Fred Zinnemann. Also up from the ranks came Jules Dassin. Arthur saw my work on the New York stage and impulsively hired me. But to do what?
You see Arthur had just seen the stage version of 'Oklahoma.' He knew a revolution in musicals was coming and he wanted to be in on the movie end of all that. He vowed no more backstage stories. He also needed new directors who could work through these problems. When I started he was having horrible problems finishing 'Panama Hattie '(1943). There was a clash between the star, Ann Sothern, and director Norman Z. McLeod, so Roy Del Ruth was brought in and I was asked to shoot a new musical number for Lena Horne.The first film Minnelli was asked to direct by himself was "Cabin in the Sky," the all-black musical that the studio saw as a test run for bigger things.
We made it for $600,000 and it made money for MGM despite restricted screenings in the South," said Minnelli. "I got veterans from the Broadway smash (Ethel Waters, Rex Ingram) and Freed added Eddie Rochester Anderson and Lena Horne."A huge cat fight ensued because Ethel thought I was throwing scenes to Lena. And she was right Lena was younger and prettier. Add Duke Ellingtons music. And I knew we might have a hit. I shot it fast to prove I could go on to bigger things.
Ethel Waters, left, the original star of "Cabin in the Sky" on Broadway,
was upset because she thought Minnelli was playing up young and beautiful
Lena Horne, right, over her, which Minnelli admits was true. Eddie "Rochester" Anderson, center, seems to be favoring Horne in this photo, too.
Minnelli spent months directing segments of "Ziegfeld Follies" in 1944 again to prove I was up to color and handling big names. He said he took the subsequent invitation to direct "Meet Me In St. Louis" quite calmly.
"But inward I was delighted," he said. "The huge sets supervised by Cedric Gibbons were already going up. Originally theyd wanted to (just) redress the Andy Hardy street.Freed had purchased the stories from The New Yorker which examined a St. Louis family circa 1903, but Mr. Mayer (MGM chief Louis B. Mayer) said there was no story line. He said to me: 'A family in St. Louis wants to move to New York. So what? One of the story readers had to act it out for him before he really got excited.
My concern was the main house looked too big, too important. After all this was going to be about an average American family to get audiences really interested.
Freed provided me with a first rate cast. Judy Garland was set as the lead but initially she said she couldnt believe in it. I told her to remember her own days as a young girl when her dad ran a movie theatre. But it took time to get her to play understated. Shed been used to big moments.
Child star Margaret O'Brien
with Judy Garland, who played
O'Brien's older sister in
"Meet Me in St. Louis."
Mary Astor and Leon Ames were perfect as the parents. Mary was only 16 years older than Judy. We wanted to emphasize her youthfulness. Did you know Van Johnson was initially the boy next door but he was recovering from a bad accident and we couldnt work around that. So in came one of MGMs spare boys next doorTom Drake. If he hadnt worked out, then it would have been Robert Walker. Marjorie Main was the housekeeper. Think of all the dusting she would have had to do in that house!
Minnelli said hed first seen Margaret OBrien in Freeds office a year earlier, All dressed in tartan. By the time wed gotten to her shed become quite the little actress, so I worked on turning her natural again. My favorite scenes include the ketchup bit where all the women are making it and some think its too sugary while others want more salt. Another is the family rushing through dinner much to Leons irritation so the trunk call can come from New York. And, of course, the whole Halloween scene, but I really didnt torture Margaret at all. Despite what she says these days. She loved the whole idea of being scared."Meet Me in St. Louis" turned out to be an enormous hit for the studio upon its release in 1944, introducing several memorable songs, including "Have Yourself A Merry Little Christmas," "The Boy Next Door" and one of Garland's biggest recording hits, "The Trolley Song."
After that triumph, Vincente Minnelli was definitely the director everybody at MGM wanted to do their next film.
NEXT WEEK: Minnelli talks about directing "The Clock," segments of "Ziegfeld Follies," "Undercurrent" with Katharine Hepburn, "Yolanda and the Thief" with Fred Astaire and "Madame Bovary" with Jennifer Jones.
©2009 by Jim Bawden. The photos are courtesy of MGM. This column first posted March 30, 2009.
TO ACCESS JIM BAWDEN'S ARCHIVE OF COLUMNS ON THIS SITE, CLICK HERE: BAWDEN ARCHIVE
You can comment on this column online. Please address your message to either "The Editors" or Jim Bawden. To send an email, click here and don't forget to mention Jim's name: talkback@thecolumnists.com
HOME About Us Index To
ArchivesTalkback Contact Us