GUEST COLUMNIST
ANTONY BUTTS
CHERNOBYL 20 YEARS LATER
ADVENTURES IN THE
DEATH ZONE ::
PART TWO
HUGE VODKA CONSUMPTION
...part of the Chernobyl legacy
This is the second of three parts. Antony Butts is a filmmaker who has recently returned from Chernobyl after documenting the legacy of the nuclear meltdown 20 years earlier. The final chapter will be in our next edition of TheColumnists.com.
In the aftermath: Slow death, alcoholism, ruinsBy ANTONY BUTTS
Special for TheColumnists.com
The men who triggered the Chernobyl disaster almost exactly 20 years ago were clearly unqualified for the work they had been assigned. The director of the power station, V.P. Bryukhanov, was not even a specialist in nuclear energy. His experience and training were in a coal-fired power plant. Anatoly Dyatlov, deputy chief engineer of reactors No. 3 and No. 4, had spent some time working with small nuclear power plants but had never dealt with the intricacies of a large reactor complex.
The accident ensued from a combination of ignorance, curiosity and blatant disregard for the safety rulebook. Bryukhanov and his comrades were running experiments that ultimately would make the reactor dangerously unstable and lead to the meltdown. As the safety systems would have interfered with the experiments, they were simply switched off.
Those in charge seemed to think that a nuclear reactor is no more dangerous than a coal-fired power station, and the result was inevitable. At his trial, Dyatlov said, with stunning understatement: ''With so many deaths, I cannot say I am completely innocent.'' He was sentenced to seven years in prison. The real death toll may be unknowable, given the latent effects of radiation. But estimates range between 4,000 and 15,000 depending on the source.
Fresh from London, I was in the Death Zone shooting my first documentary and trying to make sense of the damage 20 years on.
A statue of some communist hero stands mute overlooking the scene. It seems strange that there should be a shop here. Upon entering, one is immediately thrust back to the time of the Soviet Union. Two women with permed hair and skin that has seen too many harsh winters stand around in chequered aprons. A selection of dubious looking sausages lie on a refrigerated shelf together with bits of processed albino cheese. Apart from a few biscuits, rice and other essentials, the shelf space is devoted to alcohol. I never knew there were so many brands of vodka, most of it available at bargain prices.
At the far end of the shop there is a metal grill with a cage-like door that separates the shop from a small canteen area. Some plastic tables and chairs were scattered about. A few empty plastic cups betrayed the rooms purpose--drinking. The only sign of modernity in the shop was a large refrigerator to the left of the door, stocked with many different brands of beer. My fixer, Andriy, made straight for the fridge and quickly filled a bag with beer. Turning to one of the aproned shop assistants, he rumbled in Russian: Auntie, my dearest, be so kind as to give me that bottle of vodka over there. Ordering some cigarettes for good measure, he moved back from the counter a few paces so I could pay the bill.I speak usable Russian but for this visit I needed a translator. She was Rimma, a woman of about 50 with a bizarre, curly-blond, ginger-dyed hair-do, a slightly patronizing fixed expression and a camouflage jacket. As she speaks good English I asked her if she would help with the documentary and speak on camera. She was willing but first wanted to apply a layer or two of pancake makeup. Finally dolled up, she joined us as we all set off to Pripyat, the former home to 50,000 people and within an easy commute to the power plant, less than two kilometres away.
A large cloud of radioactivity had fallen on and around Pripyat. An accident of the wind direction meant that the smaller town of Chernobyl, being in the opposite direction, escaped comparatively unscathed. At least people could continue to live there. We drove up to the checkpoint guarding entry to the town. A couple of dogs slunk between the buildings in the city beyond. A militiaman came out of his little kiosk, checked our papers and we drove in.
Trees and bushes blocked the roads and scraped at the paint as we zigzagged through the overgrown streets. Everywhere there was leaf litter and self-seeded saplings. I looked up past the brownish bushes and trees to see steely grey communist-era tower blocks, broken windows, paint long since flaked off, steps reduced to crumbling slopes. A covering of moss bore witness to the advance of nature.
We pulled up into a wide open area dominated by low trees. It was the former football stadium.
In the early years after the accident, the Soviet government pumped serious money into research and decontamination efforts. Despite being evacuated, parts of Pripyat had been cleaned and de-contaminated by workers allowed to live there. Even the swimming pool was kept in working order. But as funding waned, the town was again abandoned and eventually comprehensively looted.
With the influx of ambitious young scientists after the accident, the most immediate environmental threats had been dealt with. And time had played its part. The worst of the radioactivity had decayed, and with it the funding. Hence the loss of amenities and the descent of Chernobyl into a town of middle-aged alcoholics. Andriy explained that it was not just archaeological relics like Chernobyl that had been frozen in time. Life in the Zone had also become a living museum of Soviet culture.
The bar where we had sipped beer and vodka was located in one of the monolithic concrete blocks that characterise almost every former Soviet town. In the dimly lit hallway we opened a door and might have stepped straight onto a 1970s film set. It looked like a cross between the Chernobyl shop and an eastern European miners dive. It was still early--about 8 p.m.--but one of the revelers, a 40-year-old man in a boiler suit, decided that it was time to go dancing. He lurched up, staggered forward a few feet and then proceeded to sway back and forth to the Russian pop music with all the skill and confidence that an afternoons vodka drinking gives you. He looked, it must be said, in the most dreadful condition. His jumpsuit was so dirty I did not know what colour it was. With the days shovelling of nuclear waste over at 4 p.m., there is nothing else to do in Chernobyl. There are few girls, and these guys were making the most of it. Its still early. Andriy drily remarked. Later is much more dancing.I had shot some atmospheric footage in the bar but was interrupted by the SBU police, the Ukrainian successor organization to the KGB, and forced to erase it all. I had no specific permission to use my camera there.
The next day at breakfast fixer Andriy greeted me with the words: Now we have lots of problems all connected with last night at the bar. I rubbed my head and ordered some strong coffee. Oh dear, I thought. That may turn out to be an expensive mistake.
But I wanted to film the reactor, so presently we were off again in search of ground zero. On Andriys instructions we detoured down some side streets and picked up Igor, a jolly little chap with a moustache. Andriy said he would be the SBUs eyes and ears on me today. He didnt look much like an SBU agent but I decided to play it safe and apart from a Hello, how are you? in Russian, I ignored him.
We soon reached the checkpoint to the inner zone--an area within a 10-kilometer radius of the destroyed reactor. Looking out of the car I could see giant fields of pylons in the distance. A few minutes later and they filled the entire left hand view. A factory-like structure with red scaffolding and a chimney dominated the right. The Chernobyl power station was made up of six reactors but it was No.4 that exploded. Reactors 5 and 6 were still being built when the blast occurred so work on these had been suspended. Their cooling towers now stood unused, grey and crumbling, half completed, the rusting iron frame upon which concrete would have been sprayed.
Even after the accident the Ukrainian government kept the first three reactors going until in 2001 international pressure finally forced them to decomission the entire site-- once a major producer of the Soviet Unions electricity. Giant lengths of aluminum pipes line the roadside linking building to building. Driving past a long concrete wall covered with barbed wire we eventually arrived at the site of the destroyed reactor.
In the days, weeks and months after the accident there had been a mad scramble to control the radiation streaming out of the reactor ruins and into the atmosphere. The Soviet Unions neighbors, especially Scandinavia, recorded alarming doses of radiation falling from the sky in the first few days. The accident was out of control.
Inside No. 4, nuclear fuel, melted by the heat of the runaway reaction, had formed a sort of molten lava that flowed through the reactor rooms, melting with and mixing with the concrete of the building. With this lava exposed to the elements and the entire building irradiated, it too became instant nuclear waste and had to be covered.
It was an unprecedented task in the brief history of nuclear power stations. The world watched in horror.
©2006 by Antony Butts All rights reserved. TheColumnists.com wishes to acknowledge the special assistance of EYE ON EUROPE Columnist Michael Johnson in arranging the publication of Mr. Butts' series on this website. The illustration is from IMSI's Master Clips Collection, 1895 Francisco Blvd. E., San Rafael, CA, 94901-5506, USA. This chapter first posted May 10, 2006.
You can comment on this column online. Please address your message to either "The Editors" or Antony Butts. To send an email, click here and don't forget to mention name: talkback@thecolumnists.com
HOME About Us Index To
ArchivesTalkback Contact Us