DONNA J. PLESH
On Television
THE NEW TV SEASON
My Name
is EarlPremieres at 9 p.m. Tues. Sept. 20 on NBC
JASON LEE as EARL HICKEY
He's a lowlife who wants
to set some things right
By DONNA J. PLESH
of TheColumnists.com
In a season where there is only one new comedy with "hit" written all over it (UPNs Everybody Hates Chris), along comes NBCs off-kilter and promising My Name is Earl. To be honest, I didnt much like Earl the first time I watched it. I liked the premise--a guy decides to right the wrongs hes done to people in his life--but I didnt particularly like the pilot.
Then, to be fair, I watched it again. And, guess what? I like it! And NBC, which desperately needs a hit--especially a hit comedy series--could have one here
However, in Earl you arent going to get something along the lines of past NBC comedy hits, such as the urbane and witty Frasier or the romantic and well-written Friends. Though created, written and executive-produced by Greg Garcia, best known for Yes, Dear, Earl is light years away from that run-of-the-mill CBS comedy.
Earl Hickey (Jason Lee ) is pretty much trailer park trash. Hes slovenly, drinks too much and doesnt have a job--unless you count robbery as a job.
He lives with his wife--the tart-ish Joy (Jamie Pressly), whom he really doesnt remember marrying because he was so drunk at the time--their two children (hes
not the biological father of either one) and his equally slovenly brother Randy (Ethan Suplee)--in a trailer. Not much of a life until one day Earl winds up with a winning lottery ticket worth $100,000.His joy is short-lived because, while doing a celebratory dance in the street, hes hit by a car and hospitalized. And the winning ticket he was holding blows away in the wind.
Hospitalized and drugged up with pain killers, Joy gets Earl to sign some papers, which turn out to be...divorce papers. Shes decided to take the kids and make a
new life with Darnell (Eddie Steeples), the owner of the bar where Earl and Randy drink pretty much continuously.
Just when things cant get any worse for Earl, he has a life-changing experience while watching Carson Daly on TV. Daly attributes his success in life to doing good things for other people. Its karma--and Earl decides the only way he can change his life and be a better person is to correct all the bad things hes done to people in the past. So, he makes a list of people he needs to do right by--a list with 259 names on it.
Out of the hospital and now living in a seedy motel with Randy, who has taken up with the sexy motel maid Catallina (Nadine Velazquez), Earl tells his brother of his new life plan and gets him to go along with it. And then something good happens--Earl finds the winning lottery ticket, claims his $100,000 reward, and sets out to right his first wrong--No. 64 on his list--by making it up to a classmate he picked on back in elementary school.
Earl is not the brightest bulb on the tree. How he goes about righting this first wrong is both humorous and, at times, poignant.
The main thing for you to do is to give Earl a chance. If you dont like the first
episode, watch another. Earl grew on me and you may find it growing on you, too.©2005 by Donna J. Plesh. The photo is courtesy of NBC. This column first posted Sept. 12, 2005.
You can comment on this column online. Please address your message to either "The Editors" or Donna J. Plesh. To send an email, click here and don't forget to mention Donna's name: talkback@thecolumnists.com
HOME About Us Index To
ArchivesTalkback Contact Us